"Made in Italy" Is a Lie: The Luxury Supply Chain Scandal Breaking Right Now

The Verdict: Toss the Entire "Luxury Heritage" Narrative

You know that feeling when you buy a "luxury Italian cashmere" sweater for $2,400 because the marketing told you it was handcrafted by artisans in Milan? Yeah. We need to talk about what's actually happening in those workshops.

Last month, the Milan Tribunal placed Loro Piana—the ultra-luxury LVMH-owned brand—under judicial administration after discovering that the company was subcontracting production to Chinese-owned sweatshops on the outskirts of Milan. Workers were making $4.85 per hour. Working 90-hour weeks. In illegal, unregulated workshops. For a brand that charges $2,000+ for a single cashmere piece.

But here's the thing: Loro Piana isn't alone. Not even close.

The Math: What You're Actually Paying For

Let me break down the Loro Piana cashmere sweater situation:

• Retail Price: $2,400
• Material Cost (cashmere): ~$80–$120
• Labor Cost (at exploitation rates): ~$4.85/hour × 8 hours = ~$38.80
• Manufacturing Overhead: ~$50–$100
• Total Production Cost: ~$170–$260
• Markup: 800–1,400%

You're paying for the idea of Italian craftsmanship. You're not paying for the craftsmanship itself. You're paying for the lie.

The Scandal Is Bigger Than One Brand

In the past 18 months, five luxury brands have been placed under court supervision for labor violations:

1. Loro Piana (LVMH) – Undocumented migrant workers, illegal subcontracting
2. Dior (LVMH) – Worker exploitation in Italian supply chain
3. Giorgio Armani – Labor abuses at supplier level
4. Valentino (Kering) – Similar supply chain violations
5. Alviero Martini – Unethical subcontracting practices

The pattern is identical across all of them: Award production contracts to shell companies with "no real manufacturing capacity." Turn a blind eye while those companies subcontract to illegal workshops. Slap a "Made in Italy" label on the finished product. Charge $2,000+.

This isn't a supply chain breakdown. This is a deliberate business model.

The "Made in Italy" Myth Is Dead

The Guardian's investigation revealed that the "Made in Italy" label doesn't mean what you think it means. A product can be labeled "Made in Italy" if the final assembly happens in Italy—even if 90% of the work was done in an illegal Chinese-owned workshop by undocumented workers.

It's the same marketing trick as "luxury," "heritage," and "artisanal." It's a story designed to justify the markup. Nothing more.

So What's the Alternative?

Here's the thing: You don't need a $2,400 Loro Piana sweater. And if you want quality cashmere, you have options that don't come with a side of labor exploitation.

The Practical Alternatives:

• Everlane Cashmere Crew Neck ($98) – Transparent pricing, ethical manufacturing, 100% cashmere. The markup is 200–300%, which is still high, but at least they're honest about it.
• Uniqlo Cashmere ($79.90) – Not designer, but genuinely well-made. If you wear it for three years, your cost-per-wear is $0.07. A Loro Piana sweater needs to last 30+ years to justify the spend.
• Reformation Cashmere ($178) – Mid-range, transparent supply chain, actually sustainable (or at least trying to be).
• Wholesale Cashmere (Direct from Mongolia) ($40–$60) – Yes, this exists. If you're willing to buy direct from producers, you can get unbranded, high-quality cashmere at 1/40th the price of Loro Piana. No "Made in Italy" label, but also no exploitation.

The cashmere itself is the same. The difference is: Are you paying for the material, or are you paying for the lie?

The Bigger Picture: Why This Matters

Luxury brands have built an entire industry on the idea of scarcity, exclusivity, and "heritage." The "Made in Italy" label is supposed to signal that you're buying something special—something handcrafted by Italian artisans with decades of expertise.

But the court findings show that's a fantasy. The brands knew (or should have known) that their products were being made in illegal workshops by exploited workers. They did it anyway because it was cheaper. Because the markup could be even higher.

And the worst part? Even after getting caught, even after being placed under court supervision, the "heritage" narrative persists. Dior and Armani had their monitoring orders lifted early because the court said they took "corrective action." But the brand image? The marketing? Still intact. Still selling the lie.

The Regret Log

I haven't bought a Loro Piana piece (thank god), but I have bought "luxury Italian" items in the past, trusting the label. If you have a $2,000+ piece from any of these brands, you're not a bad person for owning it. But you should know what you actually paid for. And you shouldn't buy another one.

Keep or Toss?

Toss the entire "Made in Italy" luxury narrative. The label is a marketing tool, not a guarantee of quality or ethics. If you want good cashmere, buy it from a brand that's transparent about where it's made and how much workers are paid. If you want to feel luxe, buy something that doesn't require labor exploitation to justify the price.

Your money is a vote. Make it count. (lol)

---

Sources: NYU Stern Center for Business & Human Rights, Business of Fashion, The Guardian, Financial Times, Glossy, WWD